19th October 2013
Egypt
Aswan.
Having landed safely and got our change from the visa
man, our fixer chap, Kamal picked us up and took us to the hotel. This was a
fairly long drive, that if we had taken a taxi we may have paid a lot, maybe
even an inflated price and we may not have found it so easy to find a taxi, so
we were very happy. The hotel is just what
we needed. Air conditioned, lovely shower, very comfortable, good price etc,
etc.
at the Philae Hotel |
The delightful staff |
Aswan is a town that is wholly dependent on tourism and as there were simply
no tourists, the situation is quite desperate. A very sorry sight is the large
number of Nile Cruise ships, moored on the bank, all lying idle.
A small part of a fleet of over 500 ships lying dormant |
When this place is crowded with tourists it is bad
enough with predatory touts everywhere, flogging souvenirs and boat trips and
all kinds tours. When you are the only tourists it is impossible. Every time
you step outside, they follow you down the street. Now they are really
struggling but to feel sorry for them is dangerously close to sharing your kids
with a lion because he looks hungry! We did have an incident where two
delightful kids attempted to pick my pocket! Suffice to say they were
‘unsuccessful’.
Actually there is more evidence of Egypt’s troubled
times apart from the complete absence of tourists. All along the main drag of
Aswan are stationed heavily armed and thoroughly bored cops, some dozing,
sprawled out in patrol cars that never move or peering out of armoured cars. Some
of it was a harsh reminder of the short time I spent in Derry all those years
ago. There is a lot of anger here against the police.
Many restaurants are closed as there is no business and
it is quite hard to find nice food. It
is very hot indeed. However, there is a Mcdonalds here which has air
conditioning and milkshakes. Sorted!
The traffic is quite strange as it seems to have waves
of being quite dense during the day and then is quiet for a while. Quiet, I use
the term advisedly as even when the road is empty with just one car it will
blow his horn every now and again for no apparent reason. Also, for reasons
that neither of us can fathom, most of the cars are fitted with some extra
noise making device and indeed many of them have got a police siren! The noise pollution
is tremendous and apparently quite pointless.
3rd October 2013
Shuffling the barges around |
On arrival, we found that the barge it was on had been
unloaded and moved off the quay to allow another barge to be unloaded and then
reloaded. Our van and our friend’s motorcycle were stuck on the barge. The
circus that followed was both dangerous and annoying in equal measure.
The bunch of amateur clowns that pass for the crew set
about swapping these vessels over, amid a tangle of ropes, a lot of chugging
back and forth and a huge amount of shouting (it seems to me that it is not
possible for Arabic speakers to raise their voice without sounding angry to my ears)
and very little leadership. Sorry lets correct that. There was rather too much
leadership as everyone wanted to have a go! It all took about an hour.
Most of the work was done by us |
With the barge in the correct position, we then set
about trying to retrieve our van, our friend’s heavy motorcycle and another
car. All 3 were crammed onto a deck between two large holds. There was no room
to manoeuvre and there was water on two sides and a 15 foot drop on the other two
sides of the barge.
The chaos that followed in the next hour or so was hazardous
and amateurish and it took several attempts for my German friend (owner of the
motor bike) and myself to get the crew to leave us alone when we were
eventually able to get our vehicles off the barge .
Finally! |
Anyway, three hours later, the paper work is completed
and we have our Egyptian number plates and off we go By now it was sufficiently late that we had
another air conditioned night in the hotel and we will move on in the morning.
Luxor
We left Aswan and drove
along the Nile route. It was an interesting drive, though it was much slower
going than we had been led to believe. We reached the town of Edfu where there
is an important temple to the God Horus, which Ping insists on pronouncing as
Horace. So Horace it shall be.
The humungous temple of Horus |
We have been quite tired and
wary of doing touristy thing. One of our friends pointed out that in view of
the fact that we are here we really should seize the opportunity and make the
effort. I do feel he has a point. So here we are in Egypt heading wards the Temple
of Horace.
Here's Horace! |
Edfu is not a huge town but as soon as we had past through the
centre we found ourselves in a road that had a high railing all along one side.
The railing had a huge empty space behind it and a row of closed down shops. On the other side of
the road was a heavily fortified wall, probably 5 metres high with gun turrets
all along it but no sign of any guns or soldiers or anything. We drove the length of this road and realised that the empty area was the car park for the temple.
Which one is the grumpy lookin bird? |
This vast car/coach park was all but
deserted. The shops we had seen were souvenir shops all closed
down and the only other
inhabitants of this space were a troop of police dotted around. It might seem
they were protecting us from terrorist, I am not sure. In addition there were
several patrols with plain clothes officers, deep under cover. They could only
be identified by the discreet machine guns that they carried.
It turned out that we were
indeed the only visitors there for quite some time. It seemed bizarre indeed
that there should be such an armed presence when there is no one to
protect. We felt quite discomforted by
being the only guests. It was very interesting to have Horace to ourselves. The
temple is really quite large and was discovered, having been covered in sand
for hundreds, possibly thousands of years. This big building was, it seems
completely covered over. When the sand
was removed, it was surprisingly well preserved. Well, we paid our entrance fee and spent a n
interesting hour and a half wandering round. We were accompanied throughout by
a man who spoke no English but was convinced he would be our guide. We didn’t
want a guide even if we could communicate, but he persisted together with a
young girl maybe 8 or 9 years who at first had tried to sell us a bracelet and
when she failed she just stuck with us throughout. It was really quite creepy.
I look like I have just finished building this |
Once we had our fill from
Horace we went back to the van to continue on to Luxor. We had the choice of
three roads to get to Luxor one on the East bank of the Nile, one on the West and a road that goes through the desert.
My esteemed life Partner had ordained that it would be much quicker to take the
desert road. Well, we spent about 45 minutes finding it as nobody seemed to know
of it.
Then at a rough estimate it turned out be about 70 or 80 km longer, but
it did get us to Luxor. It was getting late when we got into Luxor and we were
searching for a recommended camp that turned out to be closed down. Bit of a
pattern emerging here you might think.
Egyptian drivers are really
quite anarchic at any time, for example at traffic lights some people stop when
red, but only a few. Others just drive straight through as if it were not
there. At a green light, it is not uncommon for the road to be
blocked by minibuses disgorging their passengers.
I mention this because
when we were looking for a camp we stopped and asked a traffic cop. He
indicated that he knew where to go and we should follow him, so follow him we
did, red lights flashing all the way. Absolutely no one took any notice of him.
I don’t just mean they didn’t give way, some were going faster, so blew their horn
to get past, others cut him in on the inside, and despite his presence no one
stopped for the traffic lights. It was actually quite a source of worry as we
tried to stick with him. Then, without any warning, he stopped to ask
directions. Not only did this take several minutes, but nearly everyone wanted
to volunteer directions to us, in Arabic and again the cop was completely
ignored. Several people said follow my taxi which we knew was not going to be
free, one man said follow my horse and cart. It was a thoroughly bewildering
experience, not just for us, because at the end of it, the cop seemed quite
disoriented and for a few moments walked of in the opposite direction and could
not find his bike, despite it being lit up like a bloody Christmas tree.
Eventually we arrived at
the camp but not without a serious near miss where another motorbike, ignoring
the flashing lights was overtaking him as the cop turned left across his path.
I just managed to brake in time to avoid the biker who was taking evasive
action. What a palaver!
We arrived at this new
camp and settled in. We were the only guests! Aside from what seemed to be a
religious Christian gathering that involved a lot of very loud, very
enthusiastic and truly dreadful singing! Ping went to investigate and returned
to report that it was a religious karaoke. Once over at about ten pm we got to
sleep and slept quite well till the mosques started at about 4 am. It really is quite an amazing sound as one
after another starts up and the sound is all around. Amazing it may be, but it
is also quite difficult to sleep through. That was when the rooster in the
chicken shed adjacent to our van started up. We did manage to doze off again but
then the base
guitar player from the Religious Karaoke group decided that he needed more practice. I
agree with him, he did need the practice (it was truly awful) but not when I
want to sleep and not with an amplifier at full blast, but I complain too much………………….
In spite of all this, our
stay here was not bad at all. The
manager was really helpful and we had a lovely but gargantuan meal there. We
managed to visit the Temple of Luxor which is quite interesting and grand.
Karnak temple Luxor |
We
also visited the Temple of Karnak which
is about a mile down the road. This
temple is remarkable for its sheer size, its age about 3000 years and the fact that
there is an avenue of sphinxes at each of its entrances. The main avenue leads
from the Luxor temple. This is a distance of about a kilometre or more. Now, I don’t know if you think in metric or
imperial but either way that is a huge number of sphinxes. Karnak is quite
breathtaking. It is huge. We both commented that with the column and
statues and rocks around it was quite reminiscent of a large garden centre.
How many sphinxes did you order? |
The main difference being that where there
might have been working pensioners offering advice and encouragement there were
annoying ‘ne’er
do wells’ lying around and who on seeing a foreigner
took up the mantle of ‘guide’ despite not sharing any language. As far as I can
see, they
had few other skills to offer though they expect to be paid.
Western Desert
The next day we drove back along the Nile and
eventually rejoined the desert road that we had arrived on this time it would take us out into The
Western Desert.
The Western desert is in fact a continuation of the
Sahara and the locals refer to it as such. As I may have mentioned before I do
so enjoy desert driving and I was really looking forward to what would be a few days drive up to Cairo to see the pyramids at Giza.
The road takes a wide sweep around away from the
Nile and through a series of Oasis.
What a great drive! |
I am
certain that this point you have a mental picture of a pond, a couple of palm
trees a camel or two and depending on your gender there will either be man in a
dress with large curved dagger or a beautiful maiden doing the dance of the seven veils. Perlease…………
get real!
A candid shot of an Oasis town |
portable bullet proof shield - These things are everywhere i n Egypt |
Oasis dwellers |
The main Oasis are busy important towns, lots of
hustle and bustle and urban decay. There are also a string of lesser waterholes
where out of the arid desert pops a clearly defined area of deep green actually
one we saw was mainly growing flowers.
There is oasis beauty too. Flowers grown commercialy |
Rather surprisingly we have not seen a
camel since we left Luxor.
There has been a serious initiative by the
government to encourage people out to what are called The New Valleys and
extensive estates/villages have been built near these various water holes but
many of them are just empty and decaying in the desert.
We had been driving for
several hours and I was quite interested to notice that a railway crosses the
road several times which seemed odd to me. It also seemed odd that the tracks
were being taken up for relaying but that the level crossings which left a huge
deep scar in the road had been just left there. I photographed a couple of
these. Then we came to a small town where they had a delightful little station
and it started to emerge that a lot of this railway was still working, the
station was sufficiently pretty that I decided to photograph it.
A few minutes later I
noticed that a police truck was seemingly glued to my bumper. A blast from his siren brought us to a halt
and I got out to see what grief was in store for us. Four police armed
with pistols and AK-47s got out and asked the usual where are you coming from and
where are you going. Then they seemed to get frustrated by the lack of common language
and they got back in their truck and indicated that they were done with me. So
a bit mystified, we continued on our way.
On further examination of my rear view
mirror I noted that they were once again inches from my back bumper. This
continued for ten minutes or so and it was very unpleasant. Then they overtook
us. There
were a number of hand signals that made very little sense to me and then they
stopped on the side of the road. Believing that they may have thought further and
decided that there was more to investigate I once again got out and went to
speak to them. Lots of dismissive gestures and thumbs up, it seemed that this was not the case and I
was free to move on. So I did.
Mirror, signal, manoeuvre, then pull out. I got to the mirror bit and
yes there they were back on my back bumper! I can tell you it was very freaky!
I took the precaution of getting Ping to delete the railway pictures from the
camera. Just in case that was what was concerning them. We were even
considering burning any possibly incriminating documents. Burn them and chuck
them out before they can find a reason to throw us in jail! I
jest but that was how we were thinking.
Just then a filling
station came into view, so we decided to refuel and see what
happens. I pulled in and they stopped up the road. So I left Ping to fill up
and I walked out to confront them. Once again, they were all smile and reassuring
gestures. In this desert, every 50 to 100 km there is always
a police checkpoint. I was thinking
that we were being kept in view until we reached the next one where we would be
detained. We, by now were pretty alarmed. They
just were not going away.
I decided that I should show willing, as I had formed
the belief that this was something to do with photographing the railway. So I
produced the camera and showed them that there were no pictures of interest.
They got quite excited about this so I thought I had got it right. Unbelievably instead they formed up to have their
picture taken.
Safe on our watch! |
Then they managed to get
someone on the phone who spoke a bit of English , but this did not amount to an explanation only a lot
of ‘don’t worry’ and I will see you when you get here.
So we proceeded to the next checkpoint where we were
greeted by more Kalashnikovs but no English speakers. At one point we were
surrounded by happy, jovial heavily armed and (in my opinion) way too young
cops. We continued the festival of non communication until the English speaker
came on the phone again. He said ‘just drive 5 km along the road and I will be
there waiting for you’. So off we went this time another police
car peeled off to follow us. We drove 10 km with our bumper fully occupied by
police.
Then out popped a man
accompanied, even more bizarrely by 4 cyclists. It turned out that he is head
of tourism in this town and the 3 Irish and 1 Spanish cyclist are cycling from
Cairo to Cape Town.
3 Irish and one Spanish adventuers just setting out on an incredible ride of a lifetime |
Our new friend explained
that the
police do this from time to time to demonstrate that they are busy protecting
the tourists, who universally hate the experience. Oh really?!
Anyhow, we now followed our friend Mohsin, who was taking the cyclists to their hotel. We
then had to go to his office, where I was to write a demand not to be
escorted which he would translate into Arabic. Our police
car followed us until the ink
was dry and then they evaporated, like magic.
We stayed one night and
then carried on our desert journey.
What can I say about this? One might think that a huge expanse of
nothing much but sand would be pretty dull. It is not. It is exhilarating
and serenely beautiful.
Entering the Western Desert |
Simple beauty! |
As I have spoken about in
previous blogs there is a sense of danger never being far away,
though we always have
plenty of water and fuel. In this desert
the temperatures are down to about 32°C which is far lower than in Sudan. The scenery constantly
changes. We’ve run out of superlatives to describe the
beauty. Flat sand and straight road as far as the eye can see but there is so much more. There are mountain ranges in wonderful
pastel shades, huge rock outcrops
in all manner of shapes and there
is the railway which I spoke of, long and straight it is incredible that this
can continue to operate but it does.
Between these stretches of sand and rocky mountains there are the oasis
- sudden splashes of colour
and life which bring prosperity to these places.
The high spots for us both
were the areas known as The White Desert which is mile after mile of flat land
and mountains which are pure white with chalk. You will see from a distance a
lake at the side of the road. You may think it is a mirage but as you
get closer you see it’s the sun reflecting off a white area of
ground. It reflects differently to golden sand around it. It appears to be
water almost up to the point where you can touch it. There
are beautiful and bizarre shapes rising out of the sand in brilliant white chalk.
Shapes and brilliance in The White Desert |
Our desert camp |
We
stayed out here in the desert up a small hill a long way from the road. It was absolutely
stunning and
we were quite alone. Well almost. After dark I went up onto a ridge by our camp
to see the town away in the distance. As I did so in almost complete darkness I
saw the silhouette of something vaguely dog shaped pass across in front of me.
I was quite shocked and it really was as you might see in a horror movie. I
rushed back to the van to warn Ping. As I did there beside the van was a tiny
desert fox with huge pointed ears. It
was beautiful and not at all concerned about our presence,
and it hung around for much
of the evening.
We had such a lovely night
more stars and everything.
The next day we drove on
through the White desert into, yes you’ve guessed already,
Leaving camp |
The Black Desert.
Here the mountains and outcrops
and indeed sometimes the sand itself is
quite black. This I am told because there is a high content
of manganese which is oxidised
and appears black. Another extraordinary thing about desert driving
is that another time, or
someone else passing through may well have a completely different experience.
Hmmmm! oxidised manganese! |
Oasis in The Black Desert |
I could go on for hours
about this but really you had to be there. Such a good experience.
Our next destination
was for Giza and the Pyramids. I had for no good
reason been under the impression that at the end of the desert road we would come to the Pyramids.
This is the case but it seems that Cairo has sprawled out and it is not the
romantic and lovely experience that it might have been years ago.
Most importantly as much
as 60km out you start to notice the haze which I guess must be from pollution.
It just goes on and on.
Dumping on an unimaginable scale into and all around Giza |
Then about 40 km for Giza
you start to become aware that ‘fly tipping’ is really endemic all along the
side of the road for mile after mile is a continuous tip mostly of building
materials but also rotting household stuff and vegetation, even old used oil is
dumped in frequent unsightly patches.
Oh yes this was among the flytipping! |
There has been
a massive building program but
there are hundreds of blocks of flats that are completely unoccupied.
Hundreds of blocks of flats unfinished and empty |
As we approached Giza, the traffic became increasingly dense and
then
on the main road in, we discovered that some traffic was heading
toward us on the wrong side of the road. This is
something that happens in
Egypt but we were unprepared for what followed. There was a truck overturned on
the opposite carriageway and the traffic was just starting to reroute itself
into the opposite carriageway. As this progressed a level of chaos ensued the
like of which I have never seen before. Rush hour traffic going in all
directions. It was like a dodgems track
with real cars and trucks. It became clear that in Egypt if something is in
your way you go round it no matter what. It also seems without exaggeration
that when necessary the notion of driving on the right is not actually a rule
but merely a sort of custom. For me what followed was about two hours of the most
intense, chaotic
and dangerous rush hour traffic. Two hours to travel about 10 km. At the end I was totally rinsed out! We
mercifully had not collided with anyone. I just don’t know how.
We eventually found the
Salma Hotel camp which was not recommended but appeared on our GPS so we opted
to try for it. This really was a mistake and I urge other overlanders to avoid
it. We were in a difficult position as we were really tired and it was already
dark. We negotiated a price for camping and found that we were the only people
there.
The squalid bathroom at Salma Motel Camp |
The toilet and showers were in such a
dreadful state. Not only were they filthy but they were falling apart.
Only one toilet had a seat. There were no doors fitted only what were once plastic
curtains.
The showers were above the toilets and consisted only of a jet of
water from a pipe no rose or shower head. When I spoke with the manager, he said ‘well, we have not had anyone here for a year’.
‘Ok but you are open for
business and ready to take money for this.’
‘Well, we have had Germans and Italians here and
they don’t complain’.
I told him that it was
late for us to go elsewhere.
"How much would he charge for us to just park in
the car park overnight?" His reply was it didn’t matter to him if
we used the facilities
or not,
the price would be the same, take it or leave it.
I am starting now to
get very short of patience with the Egyptian way of getting money from
foreigners. I was getting mad with him and we had to stop for the night but I
really did not like it. It is all I can do to warn others which seems
pretty lame.
The next day we found
another place about 2 km away and the driving was a good deal easier. The Isis Camp is run by Sue and Helal. Very pleasant people who are open for a few
guests and have room for just one overland vehicle. Fine if you have a Land
Cruiser as room is quite restricted. We managed to fit the Iveco in, Just!
Anything larger and you would have to park on the street. The place is a haven
from the city as it is all behind a high wall. So it is pleasant and private
there is a pool and a lovely garden. In comparison to other camps it is not
cheap but it is a good place for a much needed rest.
Pyramids.
We had talked together
about whether to visit the pyramids. We felt that we are pretty overloaded with tourism.
It has been a long year. We had also been advised, quite rightly, to take full
advantage of being in Egypt and not to simply pass through. Other previous
travellers had said they felt the same way and they found you can see the
Pyramids from the road so they scooted on through.
We
decided that we should at least take in the experience. I knew that the touts
that operate there are a nuisance,
actually we were well briefed that they would be very aggressive, climb on your vehicle, pose as officials,
even as police. The little patience that I have for these people is now pretty
diminished due to our previous experiences. I decided that if we were to go
then a fairly aggressive approach was the only way to
avoid any kind of engagement with
them. I drove ‘assertively’ but when I found that there were literally
dozens of people trying to stop us in any way they could, by saying they have to check our ticket, to redirect us to their car park
or to tell us we would not
be allowed to drive and that we should go by camel /horse.
One guy said, ‘if
you drive your car up to the pyramids, you will be searched and it takes hours, but I
can
come with you and it will be easy’. So I drove faster and a bit closer to them than they were
used
to. I
felt no sympathy as they bumped into one another to get out of my way. We arrived at the car park without incident
and with me feeling a bit smug in outwitting them. Ping was a bit annoyed with me as she does
not like that kind of hard driving. I have to say I feel no empathy at all for
these crooks. There are plenty of decent people in Egypt who are having a tough
time at the moment. I think I shall empathise with them.
Once in the vehicle entrance the van was supposed to be searched but the
policeman who was quite happy to let us in was overruled by some manager who
said that a right hand drive vehicle was not allowed in as it is too dangerous!
This is in
a place where people drive on whichever side of the road that
is most convenient for
them! I put up a spirited defence saying that we’ve driven all over the continent on both
sides of the road and had no problems. So he changed tack saying that as it had
writing on the side it was a commercial tour bus and that is not allowed. Was not having that either. A more senior
manager then intervened on
our behalf,
so the first guy spoke to the cop who said there is a gas cylinder in the van
and that is not allowed. I of course spat my dummy and said that despite coming
all this way I no longer wanted to visit. I was pretty stressed by the drive in
but now I was boiling over. Ping went with the senior man to speak to the cop’s boss. He said it isn’t a problem. So off we
went with our van to see the pyramids. It was pretty amazing!
Just about the culmination of our time in Africa! |
But the hassle continued throughout the visit and it really got under my
fingernails. When
we were charged Egyptian£5 to use a manky toilet, I had just about had enough.
Mohsin, the arch diplomat |
That was when
we met with Mohsin. He was the senior manager who helped at
the gate. He greeted us like
long lost friends and took time
to talk with us not just to apologies, he was really quite embarrassed, but we
had a really enjoyable chat which to a great extent helped to change the
mood.
When we returned to our
camp I found I was completely tired out, it had been a long day. By the way The
Pyramids were pretty good but really not worth the hassle and the horrible
drives to get there but we are both glad we went.
Out of Africa
We are almost
at the end of our drive from Cairo to the east side of the
Sinai peninsula and as we cross into Sinai, we realised that we have indeed left Africa and we are now in the continent of Asia. We had to go through a long tunnel under the water so we never got to see The Suez Canal, we were very disappointed.
Entering The Suez Canal |
After that we
drove in a long V shape down one side of the peninsula to Sharm el Shaik
and then back up the other
side up to the Israel border. Last night we stayed in the car park of a holiday
resort where we were treated as a welcome guest.
We had thought
finding somewhere in Sharm
el Shaik but it was just full of expensive package tour type resorts and the
town was just like Benidorm but with very few holiday makers, The main reason
there were any was the Egyptian holiday week.
We
are about 70 Km from the Israeli border and we have stopped for the night. There is
nowhere
to stay so we have been kindly put up at one of the many emergency rescue stations in the desert.
Once again such lovely hospitality!!! It seems to me that this kind of Egyptian
behaviour puts the tourist touts further to shame.
My feelings about Egypt
are really mixed. I find that the various tombs, pyramids and archaeological sites are really only of passing interest and unless one has a strong interest in them
then they are just not worth the hassle. I genuinely regret having to say this!
Ping – It was a truly
remarkable experience to take in the pyramids after jumping through hoops to
get there – to see the only surviving monument of the 7 ancient wonders of the
world! Could have done without the hassle though!
The frequent heavily armed
police checks and vehicle searches are quite wearing and mindless. What remains with me as a
positive memory is the genuine kindness that we have received from some
remarkable ‘ordinary’ Egyptians. Our heartfelt thanks to them!
These have been days and days of overwhelming beauty. I have simply run out of superlatives to describe them. The Egyptian deserts are truly astounding. I am in danger of repeating myself but the Sianai desert is very different and is yet again stunningly beautiful.
More beauty in Sainai |
I know that we could have made so much more of this part of the journey had we the time and the nerve to leave the road more bravely.
We will toddle off to Israel tomorrow, on our way first to Jordan and then back to Israel to get the boat to Europe.
We have found a camp to stay in that has managed to stay open. It is a nice place right on the beach of the Red Sea. With the mountains of the Saudi desert just across the way. It is a lovely vista. The camp is run by a nice family who are establishing a community farm where in completely arid environment they are showing their neighbours that at a time when it exceptionally hard to make a living there are an array of cash crops to be grown. They have regular meetings with scientists and other experts so that they can build a template for other people to use to grow their own organic crops without too many problems. Very interesting!
From the deep! |
I had a diving lesson which was a really good experience although my lack of anything that looks like skill in the water rather let me down. It made it difficult for my very patient instructor, who nevertheless ensured that I had a beautiful dive on the coral reef where I saw so much of exotic fish and wonderful aquatic countryside.
That's all from Africa!
Lot of love
Ping and Noel
pingbow54@gmail.com
noelbow51@gmail.com
|
No comments:
Post a Comment